// COMPARE
Mafia II vs Red Dead Redemption
A2010 · Action
Mafia II
9.0
VAULTDGG · 1 rating
77
Metacritic
BAHEAD2010 · Action
Red Dead Redemption
8.5
VAULTDGG · 3 ratings
95
Metacritic
// VERDICT
Critics favour Red Dead Redemption, 95 to 77.
Metacritic · not enough ratings here yet
Who rates higher.
9.0VAULTDGG score8.5
1Ratings here3
77Metacritic95
1 preferRated both · 10 prefer
Who is playing and watching.
382Playing on Steam821
7Watching on Twitch40
Steam counts only Steam; Twitch only Twitch. Live, refreshed every minute.
How long they take.
16 hNormal25 h
51 hCompletionist46 h
From IGDB.com · View Mafia II on IGDB.com · View Red Dead Redemption on IGDB.com
What they are.
2010-08-24Released2010-05-18
2K CzechDeveloperRockstar North, Rockstar Games
2K Games, 1C-SoftClubPublisherRockstar Games
ActionShooterGenresActionShooter
PCPlayStation 3Xbox 360Xbox OnePlatformsPlayStation 4PCXbox Series S/XPlayStation 5Nintendo SwitchXbox One
13 hAvg playtime6 h
2 genres in common · 4 platforms in common — shown in orange.
Every rating, side by side.
101
191
8
71
6
5
4
3
2
1
1 vs 3 ratings on VAULTDGG. Scores rounded to the nearest whole number.
Keep the argument going.
VSMafia II vs Grand Theft Auto V
VSMafia II vs L.A. Noire
VSMafia II vs Assassin's Creed II
VSRed Dead Redemption vs Max Payne 3
VSRed Dead Redemption vs Far Cry 3
VSRed Dead Redemption vs Saints Row: The Third